I love these old-time entertainers--Cantor, Jolson, Chevalier, Durante, Merman, and even though he's known more for his dancing than singing, Fred Astaire knew how to put over a tune (and was a fantastic musician). None of them had "great" voices, but they just knew how to entertain musically in a way that they just don't do anymore.
The biggest problem to modern viewers is the lack of audience reaction to Eddie's punchlines, he does time the gags for films, not stage, where he would have paused even longer, before the next line.. Many stage routines were ruined by filming, timing to long or simply the silence of having no proper audience. To appreciate it you have to imagine the reaction of waves of laughter to each gag, wide eyed stare, and double take he did.
Stephen..
He was fantastic , a real performer. Black face? well, it was wrong in hindsight
but I dont think it was done with any malice. thanks forposting. Geoff. U.K.
I couldn't understand why they would allow a flub at 2:16, but realized he's changing from an old candlestick 2 piece phone to a "modern" 1 piece handset.
So I decided I should finally watch The Eddie Cantor Story, because I'm a big fan of the man. Unfortunately Keefe Brasselle is as awful as they say, so here I am trying to erase that experience from my mind.
This is apparently not even a remaster. Why is it in such good video and audio quality for 1929? Why was not everything recorded like this? Why was this not the "accepted" quality until about the 60's or 70's?! Strange.
My dad used to sing this, so I learned to play it on guitar and we had a great time with it. Now he's gone and I'm as old as he was, but the song will endure forever.